(949) 759-3600
Contact
Knee

Chondral Defects of the Knee Treatment Options

Chondral defects refer to damage to the smooth cartilage that covers the ends of the bones in the knee joint. This cartilage allows the knee to move without friction and helps absorb impact during walking, running, and sports. When knee cartilage is damaged, it has only a limited ability to heal because it lacks a direct blood supply. Over time, untreated defects can lead to pain, swelling, stiffness, and even early arthritis.

These injuries can occur from sports trauma, repetitive stress, or gradual wear and tear. Patients often describe deep knee pain, catching or locking sensations, and difficulty with activities that involve bending or loading the joint. The size, depth, and location of the defect, along with the patient’s age and activity level, determine the most appropriate treatment approach.

Dr. David Gazzaniga evaluates each case carefully to determine whether non-surgical care is appropriate or whether a surgical solution is needed to restore the cartilage surface and protect the joint long term.

When is surgery considered?

Surgical treatment is typically recommended when symptoms persist despite conservative care or when the defect is large, unstable, or causing mechanical problems in the knee. The goal is not simply to reduce pain, but to restore a smooth joint surface and prevent further joint breakdown.

There is no single procedure that works for every patient. Instead, treatment is tailored based on the characteristics of the defect and the overall alignment and stability of the knee. Here is a list of options:

An osteotomy is a procedure that realigns the knee joint to shift weight away from the damaged cartilage area. This is most often used when cartilage damage is associated with abnormal alignment, such as bow-legged or knock-kneed positioning.

During the procedure, Dr. Gazzaniga carefully cuts and reshapes the bone, typically the tibia, to redistribute forces across the knee. By unloading the damaged area, the cartilage is protected from further wear, and pain is reduced.

Osteotomy is often combined with cartilage restoration procedures to improve long-term outcomes. It is particularly useful in younger, active patients who are not ideal candidates for joint replacement.

Recovery involves a period of protected weight-bearing and physical therapy. While it requires patience, this procedure can significantly extend the life of the knee joint.

Microfracture is one of the most commonly used techniques for smaller cartilage defects. It was popularized by Dr. Steadman who Dr. Gazzaniga trained with in Vail, Colorado. It is performed arthroscopically through small incisions using a camera and specialized instruments.

Dr. Gazzaniga creates tiny holes in the bone beneath the damaged cartilage. This allows bone marrow cells to enter the area and form a new type of cartilage-like tissue. While this new tissue is not identical to original cartilage, it can provide a smoother surface and reduce symptoms.

Microfracture is best suited for smaller defects and younger patients. It is less effective for larger or more complex injuries. Recovery includes a strict rehabilitation program, often with limited weight-bearing initially to allow the new tissue to form properly. Results can be good in the right patient, but durability may decrease over time, especially in high-demand individuals.

Cartilage transplant procedures aim to replace damaged cartilage with healthy tissue. There are different approaches depending on the size and type of defect.

In some cases, small plugs of cartilage and bone are taken from a non-weight-bearing area of the patient’s own knee and transferred to the damaged area. This is known as an autograft transfer. It is typically used for small to medium defects.

This approach provides immediate structural support and uses the patient’s own tissue, which may increase the ability to incorporate. However, it is limited by how much tissue can safely be harvested.

For larger defects, an osteochondral allograft may be used. This involves transplanting cartilage and underlying bone from a donor into the damaged area of the knee.

This procedure is particularly useful when the defect is too large for other techniques or when previous treatments have failed. The donor tissue is carefully matched to the patient’s anatomy to restore the joint surface as closely as possible.

An allograft provides mature cartilage, which can offer better durability compared to some other techniques. It also allows for treatment of complex or deep defects that involve both cartilage and bone.

Recovery can take several months, with a structured rehabilitation program to protect the graft while it integrates into the patient’s knee.

MACI is an advanced cartilage restoration technique designed for larger or more complex defects. It is a two-stage procedure that uses the patient’s own cartilage cells.

In the first stage, a small sample of healthy cartilage is taken from the knee. These cells are then grown in a laboratory and placed onto a specialized scaffold. In the second stage, the scaffold with the cultured cells is implanted into the defect.

The goal of MACI is to regenerate cartilage that more closely resembles natural cartilage compared to other techniques. This can provide improved durability and function, especially for larger defects.

MACI requires a longer recovery process, including a carefully guided rehabilitation program. Patients must be committed to the process, but outcomes can be very favorable when performed in the right setting.

The decision on which procedure to use depends on multiple factors, including the size and location of the defect, the condition of the surrounding cartilage, knee alignment, and the patient’s activity goals.

Dr. David Gazzaniga is knee specialist focused on restoring knee function while protecting the joint for the future. In many cases, combining techniques such as osteotomy with cartilage restoration provides the best long-term outcome.

Chondral defects are not injuries that should be ignored. Without proper treatment, they can progress and lead to more significant joint damage. Early evaluation and a tailored treatment plan offer the best opportunity to relieve pain, restore movement, and preserve the knee for years to come. Contact Dr. Gazzaniga to schedule a consultation today to learn about your knee conditions and all your treatment options.

At a Glance

Dr. David Gazzaniga

  • Over 25 years of experience caring for professional athletes in the NHL, NFL, MLB, and the Olympics.
  • Division Chief of Sports Medicine at the Hoag Orthopedic Institute
  • Board-certified with a Certificate of Added Qualification (CAQ) in Sports Medicine and triple fellowship-trained
  • Learn more
  •